15 Comments

  1. I’m so glad you highlighted Mister Roberts’ flaws, as I’ve always struggled with this film. Fonda, Lemmon, and Powell really do carry this, but even that is still kinda cringey. I do wonder what Ford was thinking when he was directing this. Was it rushed to complete for another film? That’s how it felt to me anyway!

  2. Leah,

    Fun article! I have to say, though, I’d put Jack Lemmon in the “ham” category on this one too… It’s Powell and Fonda who keep me watching. And it’s a shame because I absolutely adore James Cagney. But whoa. He really was misdirected here.

    Best as always,

    Janet

Leave a Reply to JohnCancel reply